A Definitive Review of the Most Eco-friendly, Best Organic Mattress Toppers

by Scott Jeffrey

In this review, I’ll breakdown the best organic mattress toppers I found from my extensive research.

My Top Picks for the Best Organic Mattress Topper

Here are my top selections:

So my top five picks are:

  1. Avocado Green – Best Overall Topper
  2. Happsy – Best Value Topper
  3. Naturepedic’s Adagio – Best Luxury Topper
  4. Plushbeds Slice of Heaven – Best Pure Latex Topper
  5. White Lotus Home – Best Pure Cotton Topper

First, Why Go Natural and Organic?

In my review of the best organic mattresses, I made the case that we should all be sleeping on organic materials for both health and environmental reasons.

The main reason is VOCs or volatile organic compounds. VOCs are chemicals released into the air from your average mattress. Formaldehyde is one example.

VOCs can emit hundreds of chemicals into the air that we breathe into our bloodstream—not just when you first purchase your mattress (called off-gassing), but for years to come.

Once inhaled, VOCs can trigger a number of health problems.

And there’s an easy way to avoid these toxic chemicals: sleep on a surface made from natural, organic material that has no off-gassing or toxins of any kind.

Why Purchase a Nontoxic Mattress Topper

But there are numerous instances where an organic mattress topper is a better option than a new mattress.

For example, a natural latex and/or organic cotton topper might be best when you:

  1. Recently purchased your existing mattress.
  2. Don’t want to be wasteful and get rid of your existing mattress.
  3. Don’t have the budget for an organic mattress at the moment.

And I’m sure there are other reasons.

The main benefits of an organic or natural latex mattress topper are that you’re:

  1. Sleeping on non-toxic, healthier materials.
  2. Upgrading your sleep experience as the best organic mattress toppers support more restful sleep.

Also, if you have a non-organic or old mattress, a natural mattress topper will add additional protection from the synthetic mattress below it.

What’s an Organic Mattress Topper Made Of?

In most cases, the answer is natural latex or organic latex combined with organic cotton and/or wool. Natural latex is processed from the rubber tree.

For it to be natural latex or organic latex, it needs to be processed without any synthetic materials like petroleum. And you would be surprised how few options are genuinely “natural” and certified organic.

Many options on the market say “natural latex,” but on closer examination, they have a blend of natural and synthetic latex.

Also, most of the organic mattress toppers listed in this review have cotton covers, which are made of certified organic cotton.

My Review of the Best Organic Mattress Toppers

best organic mattress toppers avocado

Avocado Green Natural Latex Mattress Topper

If you read my analysis of the best organic mattresses, you know I have an affinity for the Avocado brand. They use the highest standards in their material selection. Everything in their mattresses is GOTS and GOLS certified organic.  And their mattress topper is no different.

The Materials:

  • 2 inches of GOLS organic certified latex harvested from tree-tapped and sustainable sources (83%)
  • GOTS organic and OEKO-TEK Standard 100 certified wool fiber (17%)
  • GOTS organic certified cotton
  • A vegan version of their organic topper is also available (no wool).

The Details:

  • Free shipping and free returns
  • 2 firmness options: plush and firm
  • 10-year limited warranted
  • Handmade in California
  • Weight ranges from 25 lbs for Twin to 42 lbs for a King
  • MADE SAFE Certified Non-Toxic
  • Carbon Neutral production and shipping
  • 100-night sleep trial
  • Pricing ranges from $349 – $549

The Best Parts:

Besides being 100% GOTS certified organic, Avocado gives you the choice of either a plush or firm mattress topper. The firm topper gives you more of a gentle, resilient support. The plush topper provides a more luxury-plush experience.

Plus, unlike most of its competitors, the organic cotton cover has a zipper in case you need to adjust the natural latex inside. (However, the cover isn’t washable.)

The Bottom Line: 

The Avocado Green Topper is an excellent product at a competitive price. If I was going to feature only one organic mattress topper in this review, Avocado would be it.

best mattress topper happsy

Happsy Organic Mattress Topper

Happsy is another mattress brand that I featured in my organic mattress review.

Happsy is a no-thrills brand that offers all of the certified organic materials you would expect.

The Materials:

  • 2 inches of GOLS Organic Certified natural Dunlop latex
  • Certified organic cotton cover

The Details:

  • Free shipping and returns
  • MADE SAFE Certified Non-Toxic
  • Made in the USA
  • Cover is nonremovable
  • 120-night trial
  • Prices range from $249 for a Twin to $499 for a King size

The Bottom Line:

The Happsy Topper is straightforward with no options other than mattress sizes. But their topper is 100% certified organic and slightly cheaper than Avocado.

Adagio Organic Latex Topper by Naturepedic

Naturepedic is one of three brands that have the GOTS certified for organic cotton and natural latex (Avocado and Happsy are the other two).

Naturepedic’s Adagio Latex Topper is another excellent organic option that provides sleepers with a “nesting” feeling.

The Materials:

  • GOLS certified organic latex
  • GOTS certified organic cotton cover

The Details:

  • Free shipping and free returns
  • 2 inches of natural, organic latex
  • MADE SAFE Certified Non-Toxic
  • Made in the USA
  • 90-day sleep trial
  • Prices range from $499 to $849

The Bottom Line:

Adagio Organic Latex Topper by Naturepedic is a fully GOTS organic certified mattress topper with a smooth, luxury feel that will help relieve pressure points.

best natural latex topper

Plushbeds Natural Latex Organic Topper

If you’re looking for a pure, natural latex mattress topper, Plushbeds is a good way to go.

With multiple thickness and firmness options, as well as an optional organic cotton cover, Plush Beds Natural Latex Topper offers you everything you need at an affordable price.

The Materials:

  • 100% Natural Talalay Latex
  • Organic cotton cover (if you select this option)
  • NOTE: This product is not GOTS certified organic from materials to factory

The Details:

  • Free shipping
  • Non-returnable (no sleep trial)
  • Select either 2” or 3” natural latex thickness
  • Select from four firmness options: soft, medium, medium-firm, extra-firm
  • Made in the USA
  • Lifespan of up to 20 years (according to their website)
  • Prices range from $219 for a 2-inch Twin to $619 for 3-inch King

The Best Part:

The best thing about Plushbed’s Natural Latex Topper is the versatility in customizing the topper just the way you want it.

The Bottom Line:

Plushbeds makes solid, natural latex mattresses and toppers. The main downside is that they aren’t returnable, if you find this topper doesn’t suit you.

White Lotus Home Cotton Mattress Topper

For various reasons, some individuals may be searching for a 100% organic cotton mattress topper (with no latex0.

I was in this camp several years ago. I was concerned about the sustainability of tapping rubber trees (for natural latex) and so I wanted to get a topper that was 100% certified organic. It wasn’t an easy feat until I discovered White Lotus.

At that time, White Lotus Home didn’t have much of an online presence and they certainly weren’t available on Amazon. They had a small retail location in New Jersey and I drove several hours to check them out.

The Materials: 

  • 100% GOTS Certified Organic Cotton inside (2-inch thickness)
  • 100% GOTS Certified Organic Cotton Twill case

The Details:

  • Free shipping
  • 30-day returns if the item is unused (no sleep trial)
  • Available in 2-inch and 4-inch thickness
  • 100% certified organic cotton batting and cover
  • Handmade in the USA (New Jersey)
  • Cost ranges from $357 for a 2-inch Twin to $857 for  4-inch King

The Best Part:

No latex. No wool. Just 100% GOTS certified organic cotton.

The Bottom Line: 

If you’re in the market for a 100% organic cotton mattress topper, White Lotus Home is the way to go.

Which Natural Toppers Have the Highest Standards?

If you’re looking for the highest standard in GOTS certified organic including the materials, the finished product, and the factory itself, only three brands pass this test:

  1. Avocado,
  2. Happsy, and
  3. Naturepedic.

These three brands are also the only Made Safe certified products. This means that they contain no materials considered to be harmful to human health.

So What is the Best Organic Mattress Topper?

All of the natural mattress toppers I reviewed above are made with top-quality, certified organic materials.

But if I had to choose one from this excellent list, for most shoppers, the Avocado Green Topper is probably the best way to go.

What Do You Think?

Share your thoughts and experiences below.